Docker and the Device Mapper storage driver

Device Mapper is a kernel-based framework that underpins many advanced volume management technologies on Linux. Docker’s devicemapper storage driver leverages the thin provisioning and snapshotting capabilities of this framework for image and container management. This article refers to the Device Mapper storage driver as devicemapper, and the kernel framework as Device Mapper.

Note: The Commercially Supported Docker Engine (CS-Engine) running on RHEL and CentOS Linux requires that you use the devicemapper storage driver.

An alternative to AUFS

Docker originally ran on Ubuntu and Debian Linux and used AUFS for its storage backend. As Docker became popular, many of the companies that wanted to use it were using Red Hat Enterprise Linux (RHEL). Unfortunately, because the upstream mainline Linux kernel did not include AUFS, RHEL did not use AUFS either.

To correct this Red Hat developers investigated getting AUFS into the mainline kernel. Ultimately, though, they decided a better idea was to develop a new storage backend. Moreover, they would base this new storage backend on existing Device Mapper technology.

Red Hat collaborated with Docker Inc. to contribute this new driver. As a result of this collaboration, Docker’s Engine was re-engineered to make the storage backend pluggable. So it was that the devicemapper became the second storage driver Docker supported.

Device Mapper has been included in the mainline Linux kernel since version 2.6.9. It is a core part of RHEL family of Linux distributions. This means that the devicemapper storage driver is based on stable code that has a lot of real-world production deployments and strong community support.

Image layering and sharing

The devicemapper driver stores every image and container on its own virtual device. These devices are thin-provisioned copy-on-write snapshot devices. Device Mapper technology works at the block level rather than the file level. This means that devicemapper storage driver’s thin provisioning and copy-on-write operations work with blocks rather than entire files.

Note: Snapshots are also referred to as thin devices or virtual devices. They all mean the same thing in the context of the devicemapper storage driver.

With devicemapper the high level process for creating images is as follows:

1. The devicemapper storage driver creates a thin pool.

   The pool is created from block devices or loop mounted sparse files (more on this later).

2. Next it creates a base device.

   A base device is a thin device with a filesystem. You can see which filesystem is in use by running the docker info command and checking the Backing filesystem value.

3. Each new image (and image layer) is a snapshot of this base device.

   These are thin provisioned copy-on-write snapshots. This means that they are initially empty and only consume space from the pool when data is written to them.

With devicemapper, container layers are snapshots of the image they are created from. Just as with images, container snapshots are thin provisioned copy-on-write snapshots. The container snapshot stores all updates to the container. The devicemapper allocates space to them on-demand from the pool as and when data is written to the container.

The high level diagram below shows a thin pool with a base device and two images.

If you look closely at the diagram you’ll see that it’s snapshots all the way down. Each image layer is a snapshot of the layer below it. The lowest layer of each image is a snapshot of the the base device that exists in the pool. This base device is a Device Mapper artifact and not a Docker image layer.

A container is a snapshot of the image it is created from. The diagram below shows two containers - one based on the Ubuntu image and the other based on the Busybox image.

Reads with the devicemapper

Let’s look at how reads and writes occur using the devicemapper storage driver. The diagram below shows the high level process for reading a single block (0x44f) in an example container.

1. An application makes a read request for block 0x44f in the container.

   Because the container is a thin snapshot of an image it does not have the data. Instead, it has a pointer (PTR) to where the data is stored in the image snapshot lower down in the image stack.

2. The storage driver follows the pointer to block 0xf33 in the snapshot relating to image layer a005....

3. The devicemapper copies the contents of block 0xf33 from the image snapshot to memory in the container.

4. The storage driver returns the data to the requesting application.

Write examples

With the devicemapper driver, writing new data to a container is accomplished by an allocate-on-demand operation. Updating existing data uses a copy-on-write operation. Because Device Mapper is a block-based technology these operations occur at the block level.

For example, when making a small change to a large file in a container, the devicemapper storage driver does not copy the entire file. It only copies the blocks to be modified. Each block is 64KB.

Writing new data

To write 56KB of new data to a container:

1. An application makes a request to write 56KB of new data to the container.

2. The allocate-on-demand operation allocates a single new 64KB block to the container’s snapshot.

   If the write operation is larger than 64KB, multiple new blocks are allocated to the container’s snapshot.

3. The data is written to the newly allocated block.

Overwriting existing data

To modify existing data for the first time:

1. An application makes a request to modify some data in the container.

2. A copy-on-write operation locates the blocks that need updating.

3. The operation allocates new empty blocks to the container snapshot and copies the data into those blocks.

4. The modified data is written into the newly allocated blocks.

The application in the container is unaware of any of these allocate-on-demand and copy-on-write operations. However, they may add latency to the application’s read and write operations.

Configuring Docker with Device Mapper

The devicemapper is the default Docker storage driver on some Linux distributions. This includes RHEL and most of its forks. Currently, the following distributions support the driver:

• RHEL/CentOS/Fedora
• Ubuntu 12.04
  
• Ubuntu 14.04
  
• Debian
  

Docker hosts running the devicemapper storage driver default to a configuration mode known as loop-lvm. This mode uses sparse files to build the thin pool used by image and container snapshots. The mode is designed to work out-of-the-box with no additional configuration. However, production deployments should not run under loop-lvm mode.

You can detect the mode by viewing the docker info command:

$ sudo docker info
Containers: 0
Images: 0
Storage Driver: devicemapper
 Pool Name: docker-202:2-25220302-pool
 Pool Blocksize: 65.54 kB
 Backing Filesystem: xfs
 ...
 Data loop file: /var/lib/docker/devicemapper/devicemapper/data
 Metadata loop file: /var/lib/docker/devicemapper/devicemapper/metadata
 Library Version: 1.02.93-RHEL7 (2015-01-28)
 ...

The output above shows a Docker host running with the devicemapper storage driver operating in loop-lvm mode. This is indicated by the fact that the Data loop file and a Metadata loop file are on files under /var/lib/docker/devicemapper/devicemapper. These are loopback mounted sparse files.

Configure direct-lvm mode for production

The preferred configuration for production deployments is direct lvm. This mode uses block devices to create the thin pool. The following procedure shows you how to configure a Docker host to use the devicemapper storage driver in a direct-lvm configuration.

Caution: If you have already run the Docker daemon on your Docker host and have images you want to keep, push them Docker Hub or your private Docker Trusted Registry before attempting this procedure.

The procedure below will create a 90GB data volume and 4GB metadata volume to use as backing for the storage pool. It assumes that you have a spare block device at /dev/xvdf with enough free space to complete the task. The device identifier and volume sizes may be be different in your environment and you should substitute your own values throughout the procedure. The procedure also assumes that the Docker daemon is in the stopped state.

1. Log in to the Docker host you want to configure and stop the Docker daemon.

2. If it exists, delete your existing image store by removing the /var/lib/docker directory.

   $ sudo rm -rf /var/lib/docker
   

3. Create an LVM physical volume (PV) on your spare block device using the pvcreate command.

   $ sudo pvcreate /dev/xvdf
   Physical volume `/dev/xvdf` successfully created
   

   The device identifier may be different on your system. Remember to substitute your value in the command above.

4. Create a new volume group (VG) called vg-docker using the PV created in the previous step.

   $ sudo vgcreate vg-docker /dev/xvdf
   Volume group `vg-docker` successfully created
   

5. Create a new 90GB logical volume (LV) called data from space in the vg-docker volume group.

   $ sudo lvcreate -L 90G -n data vg-docker
   Logical volume `data` created.
   

   The command creates an LVM logical volume called data and an associated block device file at /dev/vg-docker/data. In a later step, you instruct the devicemapper storage driver to use this block device to store image and container data.

   If you receive a signature detection warning, make sure you are working on the correct devices before continuing. Signature warnings indicate that the device you’re working on is currently in use by LVM or has been used by LVM in the past.

6. Create a new logical volume (LV) called metadata from space in the vg-docker volume group.

   $ sudo lvcreate -L 4G -n metadata vg-docker
   Logical volume `metadata` created.
   

   This creates an LVM logical volume called metadata and an associated block device file at /dev/vg-docker/metadata. In the next step you instruct the devicemapper storage driver to use this block device to store image and container metadata.

7. Start the Docker daemon with the devicemapper storage driver and the --storage-opt flags.

   The data and metadata devices that you pass to the --storage-opt options were created in the previous steps.

     $ sudo docker daemon --storage-driver=devicemapper --storage-opt dm.datadev=/dev/vg-docker/data --storage-opt dm.metadatadev=/dev/vg-docker/metadata &
     [1] 2163
     [root@ip-10-0-0-75 centos]# INFO[0000] Listening for HTTP on unix (/var/run/docker.sock)
     INFO[0027] Option DefaultDriver: bridge
     INFO[0027] Option DefaultNetwork: bridge
     <output truncated>
     INFO[0027] Daemon has completed initialization
     INFO[0027] Docker daemon commit=0a8c2e3 execdriver=native-0.2 graphdriver=devicemapper version=1.8.2
   

   It is also possible to set the --storage-driver and --storage-opt flags in the Docker config file and start the daemon normally using the service or systemd commands.

8. Use the docker info command to verify that the daemon is using data and metadata devices you created.

   $ sudo docker info
   INFO[0180] GET /v1.20/info
   Containers: 0
   Images: 0
   Storage Driver: devicemapper
    Pool Name: docker-202:1-1032-pool
    Pool Blocksize: 65.54 kB
    Backing Filesystem: xfs
    Data file: /dev/vg-docker/data
    Metadata file: /dev/vg-docker/metadata
   [...]
   

   The output of the command above shows the storage driver as devicemapper. The last two lines also confirm that the correct devices are being used for the Data file and the Metadata file.

Examine devicemapper structures on the host

You can use the lsblk command to see the device files created above and the pool that the devicemapper storage driver creates on top of them.

$ sudo lsblk
NAME                       MAJ:MIN RM  SIZE RO TYPE MOUNTPOINT
xvda                       202:0    0    8G  0 disk
└─xvda1                    202:1    0    8G  0 part /
xvdf                       202:80   0   10G  0 disk
├─vg--docker-data          253:0    0   90G  0 lvm
│ └─docker-202:1-1032-pool 253:2    0   10G  0 dm
└─vg--docker-metadata      253:1    0    4G  0 lvm
  └─docker-202:1-1032-pool 253:2    0   10G  0 dm

The diagram below shows the image from prior examples updated with the detail from the lsblk command above.

In the diagram, the pool is named Docker-202:1-1032-pool and spans the data and metadata devices created earlier. The devicemapper constructs the pool name as follows:

Docker-MAJ:MIN-INO-pool

MAJ, MIN and INO refer to the major and minor device numbers and inode.

Because Device Mapper operates at the block level it is more difficult to see diffs between image layers and containers. Docker 1.10 and later no longer matches image layer IDs with directory names in /var/lib/docker. However, there are two key directories. The /var/lib/docker/devicemapper/mnt directory contains the mount points for image and container layers. The /var/lib/docker/devicemapper/metadatadirectory contains one file for every image layer and container snapshot. The files contain metadata about each snapshot in JSON format.

Device Mapper and Docker performance

It is important to understand the impact that allocate-on-demand and copy-on-write operations can have on overall container performance.

Allocate-on-demand performance impact

The devicemapper storage driver allocates new blocks to a container via an allocate-on-demand operation. This means that each time an app writes to somewhere new inside a container, one or more empty blocks has to be located from the pool and mapped into the container.

All blocks are 64KB. A write that uses less than 64KB still results in a single 64KB block being allocated. Writing more than 64KB of data uses multiple 64KB blocks. This can impact container performance, especially in containers that perform lots of small writes. However, once a block is allocated to a container subsequent reads and writes can operate directly on that block.

Copy-on-write performance impact

Each time a container updates existing data for the first time, the devicemapper storage driver has to perform a copy-on-write operation. This copies the data from the image snapshot to the container’s snapshot. This process can have a noticeable impact on container performance.

All copy-on-write operations have a 64KB granularity. As a results, updating 32KB of a 1GB file causes the driver to copy a single 64KB block into the container’s snapshot. This has obvious performance advantages over file-level copy-on-write operations which would require copying the entire 1GB file into the container layer.

In practice, however, containers that perform lots of small block writes (<64KB) can perform worse with devicemapper than with AUFS.

Other device mapper performance considerations

There are several other things that impact the performance of the devicemapper storage driver.

• The mode. The default mode for Docker running the devicemapper storage driver is loop-lvm. This mode uses sparse files and suffers from poor performance. It is not recommended for production. The recommended mode for production environments is direct-lvm where the storage driver writes directly to raw block devices.

• High speed storage. For best performance you should place the Data file and Metadata file on high speed storage such as SSD. This can be direct attached storage or from a SAN or NAS array.

• Memory usage. devicemapper is not the most memory efficient Docker storage driver. Launching n copies of the same container loads n copies of its files into memory. This can have a memory impact on your Docker host. As a result, the devicemapper storage driver may not be the best choice for PaaS and other high density use cases.

One final point, data volumes provide the best and most predictable performance. This is because they bypass the storage driver and do not incur any of the potential overheads introduced by thin provisioning and copy-on-write. For this reason, you should to place heavy write workloads on data volumes.

Related Information

• Understand images, containers, and storage drivers
• Select a storage driver
• AUFS storage driver in practice
• Btrfs storage driver in practice